How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

A while back I had a reader who asked How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows .
This inquiry was because she was concerned with the malitol that is in products that are for sale.

How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

I have used sugar free marshmallows in the past recipes.
You may remember seeing marshmallows in my Sugar Free Rice Krispie Treats or my Sugar Free S’More recipes.

Marshmallows are just one of those yummy treats that we have to give up when we opt to cut out sugar from our diet.
I certainly remember the agony of having to avoid a S’more one summer at a barbecue because of the sugar in it. I mean, sure there are (at least) three layers of sugar in an average S’More. But, they are also synonymous with a summer cookout.

Needless to say, it was a happy day for me when I discovered that there is a such thing as sugar free marshmallows.

You can easily buy your own sugar free marshmallows online. While they are not as inexpensive as regular marshmallows, they are more convenient than making your own. Also, I like that they often come in colors.

Sometimes however, you want to have control over the ingredients that you put into what you make.
Thus, making your own marshmallows can be a good idea as well. The big problem for us is that marshmallows are normally made with corn syrup. Corn syrup contains sugar. Thus we need to work around this.

Want to learn more about using sugar alternatives?

You can check out my guide on baking with sugar alternatives on Amazon
I have some great tips on which alternatives may work in a recipe such as this one.

Be sure to follow me on facebook and subscribe to my recipes via email to keep up to date as well.

How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

The recipe for How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

This is basically a gelatin based recipe rather than a recipe that calls for a bunch of ingredients that you may not be about to pronounce or spell (I speak for myself here).

What you will need to make this recipe.

• Sugar free powdered sugar- enough for dusting your pan with.
• Gelatin Packets – 2 unflavored. it is easiest to use packets rather than measuring your own. You can find gelatin packets online. Each packet is about 2 tablespoons. Be sure to use unsweetened gelatin.
• Water- 1/2 cup cold water.
• Sugar alternative- granular works best. Use the equivalent to 2 cups of sugar.
• Water- 1/2 cup additional
• Vanilla Extract 3 teaspoons.
• Optional- salt 1/2 teaspoon.

How to make How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

• Prep a non metal baking dish with sugar free powdered sugar and then set this aside.
• In a mixing bowl (that you will be using with a mixer later on), combine together the gelatin packets and 1/2 cup of the cold water. Allow this to sit while you continue to work.
• Meanwhile, in a sauce pan set on medium, combine together your sugar alternative, optional salt  and the remaining water. Stirring as you go, allow this to just about bubble( 8-10 minutes). Remove this from heat and stir in the vanilla extract.
• Now, start your mixer on slow (whisk attachment works best for me) with the first bowl that you had set aside. Gradually pour the contents of the second bowl along the inside of the mixing bowl. Allow the mixture to double in size- takes about 12-14 minutes in the mixer.
• Once the mixture has doubles in size, you can pour it into your prepped pans. Some folks like to sprinkle additional powdered sugar (alternative) on top of this. Allow it to cool uncovered before cutting into squares.
• Store your marshmallow covered in the refrigerator.

4.46 from 24 votes

(Click Here to Print)

How to Make Sugar Free Marshmallows

Prep Time

20 mins

Total Time

1 hr 20 mins

 

Make your own sugar free marshmallows with this recipe. Then, you can use them in recipes such as my sugar free s'mores or cereal treats!

Ingredients

• Sugar free powdered sugar- enough for dusting your pan with.
• Gelatin Packets - 2 unflavored. it is easiest to use packets rather than measuring your own. You can find gelatin packets online. Each packet is about 2 tablespoons. Be sure to use unsweetened gelatin.
• Water- 1/2 cup cold water.
• Sugar alternative- granular works best. Use the equivalent to 2 cups of sugar.
• Water- 1/2 cup additional
• Vanilla Extract 3 teaspoons.
• Optional- salt 1/2 teaspoon.

Instructions

1. Prep a non metal baking dish with sugar free powdered sugar and then set this aside.
2. In a mixing bowl (that you will be using with a mixer later on), combine together the gelatin packets and 1/2 cup of the cold water. Allow this to sit while you continue to work.
3. Meanwhile, in a sauce pan set on medium, combine together your sugar alternative, optional salt  and the remaining water. Stirring as you go, allow this to just about bubble( 8-10 minutes). Remove this from heat and stir in the vanilla extract.
4. Now, start your mixer on slow (whisk attachment works best for me) with the first bowl that you had set aside. Gradually pour the contents of the second bowl along the inside of the mixing bowl. Allow the mixture to double in size- takes about 12-14 minutes in the mixer.
5. Once the mixture has doubles in size, you can pour it into your prepped pans. Some folks like to sprinkle additional powdered sugar (alternative) on top of this. Allow it to cool uncovered before cutting into squares.
6. Store your marshmallow covered in the refrigerator.

Recipe Notes

See post for ingredient details etc.